Caranthir is one of my personal favorites.

Great idea that sending Caranthir to Thargelion was a type of banishment of sorts, for lashing out at Angrod in 'that' council meeting.

Such a lonely character and a little misunderstood by others. I think that's why I like him so much.

Thank you for sharing.

It hadn't occurred to me that that prompt just cried out for Helevorn fic, but of course it does!

Poor Caranthir! The lake clearly was one of the few good things, for him, in Middle-earth, and then he lost that, too.