Another enjoyable story, I especially liked viewing the events from Caranthir's POV.   The parting of the lovers was heartbreaking and given all they had to suffer secretly at least they had each other for a short time.

I'm surprised this has not recieved more reviews! I like the idea of Caranthir and Haleth marrying. It seems to work in some weird but wonderful way.

Haleth is definitly an odd one in Tolkiens works; one of the only mortal women to play a major part in his tale. she fits with Caranthir I think and both were very in character. Your depictions of them both were spot on. I enjoyed reading this story very much, I only wish there was more...

Thanks :)