Founded in 2005, the Silmarillion Writers' Guild exists for discussions of and creative fanworks based on J.R.R. Tolkien's The Silmarillion and related texts. We are a positive-focused and open-minded space that welcomes fans from all over the world and with all levels of experience with Tolkien's works. Whether you are picking up Tolkien's books for the first time or have been a fan for decades, we welcome you to join us!
Mereth Aderthad Interview: Interview with polutropos by Dawn "And love grew after between them"—those words have fascinated a fandom intent on revealing the how and why of the "kidnap fam" plot point in "The Silmarillion." In this interview, polutropos discusses her upcoming Mereth Aderthad paper on the topic, “'Kidnap Fam' and the Living Legendarium."
Mereth Aderthad Interview: Interview with Maglor by Shadow Who is Gil-galad? That might seem a silly question, but we know very little of his character beyond his kingship. In this interview, Shadow talks with Maglor about his upcoming Mereth Aderthad presentation "Gil-galad was an Elven King: Kingship and Personhood in the Last High King of the Noldor" that explores who Gil-galad might have been, beyond the last king of the Noldor.
Mereth Aderthad Registration Is Open! Registration for attending Mereth Aderthad is open for both in-person and virtual attendees and will remain open through the day of the event.
New Challenge: Birthday Bash In honor of our twentieth birthday, we look back at twenty years of SWG history with a new poetry, image, and word prompt each day.
Eärendil has to find his way in this unfamiliar land. Luckily (or unluckily, depending on your point of view) for him, it's a time of festival in Valimar...
They passed out of Lhûn and the wider coastline of Middle-earth opened up before his eyes. He had wandered those shores for centuries, and even now he felt the pull of that same wanderlust, and knew he would miss them for the rest of his life. Their wildness, the untamed waves, the rocky…
Dawn spoke with polutropos about her upcoming presentation for Mereth Aderthad, “'Kidnap Fam' and the Living Legendarium," including the appeal of kidnap fam, the appeal of Maglor's character, and how The Silmarillion as an incomplete, complex word makes it ripe for both fanworks and…
As one of the most beloved Silmarillion characters, Maglor is a bundle of contradictions undergirded by a complex textual history. Warrior, musician, wanderer, and survivor, Maglor brings to the fore key themes in Tolkien's early legendarium, such as the role of music, oaths, and exile…
Current Challenge
Birthday Bash
Daily word, image, and poetry prompts are loosely structured around events and milestones leading up to our 20th birthday. Read more ...
Dawn spoke with polutropos about her upcoming presentation for Mereth Aderthad, “'Kidnap Fam' and the Living Legendarium," including the appeal of kidnap fam, the appeal of Maglor's character, and how The Silmarillion as an incomplete, complex word makes it ripe for both fanworks and scholarship.
As one of the most beloved Silmarillion characters, Maglor is a bundle of contradictions undergirded by a complex textual history. Warrior, musician, wanderer, and survivor, Maglor brings to the fore key themes in Tolkien's early legendarium, such as the role of music, oaths, and exile.
Maglor spoke with Shadow about his upcoming presentation for Mereth Aderthad, "Gil-galad was an Elven King: Kingship and Personhood in the Last High King of the Noldor," and what makes Gil-galad such an intriguing—and mysterious—character.
Part of our Themed Collection series for our newsletter, this collection features fiction, artwork, and essays that transcend the idea of Orcs as the enemy, instead considering their humanity.
One wrong decision can make a world of difference. When one of the Fellowship makes the mistake, the consequences are so severe that only the Valar can repair it. But will they?
Glorfindel daughter's life is in Elrohir's hands and only she remembers th eir love for each other. The fate of…
The Gardens of the Entwives are fallen, but two Entwives remain.
Around the World and Web
Celedriel Week 2025
Celedriel Week is a Tumblr events for fanworks about Galadriel and Celeborn.
Neurodivergent Arda Week 2025
Neurodivergent Arda Week is a Tumblr event to celebrate neurodiversity in Tolkien's works.
Tolkien at UVM Registration Open
The theme for this hybrid conference is Tolkien and War with John Garth as the keynote speaker.
Tolkien Ekphrasis Week 2025
This is a Tolkien-fandom-wide event dedicated to the art of ekphrasis in Tolkien's worlds. Its goal is to illuminate the artistic surroundings of the places, people, and stories we love, in as many media as possible.
Feanorian Week 2025
Feanorian Week is a Tumblr event offering optional prompts for fanworks about the sons of Feanor and their parents.
The first problem is that there are simply not enough children.
Among the hosts of the Noldor, only twenty-two remain of the appropriate age and temperament to render Maglor’s vision. He can see it in his mind’s eye as he would have cast it for the stage in Tirion: thirty-six small bodies of perfectly equal height, their hair falling dark and pure against their silken gowns. Lantern-bearers. Wisdom-carriers. Bringers of light.
But there are only twenty-two, and those ill-matched. All dark, true, but some tall, some short, more than one halting from an injury on the Ice. Their people are unlikely to beget in the stress of war, and those who have done so guard their children jealously, as treasures far more precious than anything they have already lost to the snow or the flames. The littler ones will not be shared for this festival, nor indeed are they of an age to balance grace with joy, as he envisions.
There is nothing for it but to borrow from the Sindar. The children of Mithrim are by nature smaller and lighter than the Noldor; there will be no perfect symmetry. But there is something to a blended rank, a gesture to their hopes for integration. It will have to do.
And of course there is no silk, or not enough for theater!, as Caranthir tells him with an astounded roar when Maglor queries him on their stocks. What have they come to, that he must tear and recombine their linen sheets, cramping his own hands with needlework to fit frills to collars and hems?
Lanterns are easy enough to make, however, with willow-withies and the fine-scraped skins of rabbits and of deer. Thin enough to shed a gentle light, soothing and uplifting. Not the glory of the pierced brass pendants of Valinor, the luminaria crafted of bone or stone, or the hallowed Fëanorian lamps. But the softer glow suits this new landscape. It offers tenderness, as well as light. Very satisfactory, in terms of mood.
He is deep into rehearsals with his cast of little lantern-bearers when the greatest gaffe occurs.
Daeron of Doriath, scouting the Noldor ahead of the feast of reuniting, sniffs out the local drama and sidles into the clearing where the processional has convened. He watches and listens with amusement, silvery and wry, his eyebrows creeping slowly higher and higher the longer the children sing.
Maglor frowns, waving the little ones through their paces, listening as each sings the merits of a tengwa – gesturing for telco and lúva, telling the tale of the meaning of each letter, elucidating how they capture sound in sight. It is a Great Work they are illustrating in song: an elevation of the Speaking Peoples. Father’s own foundational achievement (yes, after Rumil, yes, yes): binding meaning into ink, taming memory’s darkness, letting in the light.
Daeron’s quirked mouth and ironic brow are not at all what Maglor hoped to achieve with this didactic art. The Noldor have much to offer these people of the mists and groves: work of their hands finer than any to be found here, to be sure, but even more so the work of their hearts. Capturing language! Writing down their thinking, their feeling, their imagining!
Maglor’s own heart sinks at the thought that the smirking Sinda might represent a world of people with no use or taste for script. He pastes on his most welcoming, professional smile and introduces himself, ready with a simplified explanation of the pageantry and of its desired effect.
Daeron smiles and nods and pats the children approvingly on their heads as Maglor expounds.
“It’s lovely and instructive,” he agrees. “How fortunate that I stopped by and heard your alphabet in song, with the feast still a full moon away. That will give me time to pull together a little lesson - for comparison, you know - on the source and shapes and meanings of the letters of my own.”
John Singer Sargent, 1885
Chapter End Notes
The lamps in the gorgeous banner for the calma prompt for this challenge reminded me of this painting, which I have always loved. Imagine the children are Maglor’s little artistes, getting ready to perform their alphabet song, with lanterns symbolizing the light of the mind. Noldor: always given to such overwrought metaphors!
Maglor hasn't paid attention to the Cirth before because he's an absolute snob. Hot Daeron's certainly gotten his attention now, though...