Lovely story! I like very much to think about Elrond's relationship to Maedhros and Maglor.

But I think he imagines that there are dark hurtful secrets in our past that we aren’t revealing, obscure Feanorian transgressions.  There are no sinister Feanorian secrets, though. All Maedhros and Maglor’s crimes are public knowledge.

Beautifully put.

‘You've already thought of one? That was quick... Very polite of you, Elrond-I had expected something much less poetic... Thank you very much.'

Of course, I am absolutely dying to know what the name was that Elrond gave him.