I have seen a lot of blatantly uncanonical writing on the other side of the question, Your tone in this story is incredibly mild by comparison.

Oh! This is an excellent approach! I confronted Maedhros with Thingol once, so your idea here is very appealing to me. Well done!

I wager my letter will go down in Sindarin history as the most impudent demand ever made of the King of Doriath

::lol:: Everything they said was doomed to fail but hey, they had to try, right? It reminds me of that quote: You have the right to remain silent. Anything you say will be misquoted and then used against you.

This is "The Good, the Bad and the Queen" you are talking about?

Yes, that's the story :)