Comments

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.

WoW! I love humorous Silmarillion and this is quite outrageous! :D:D

I agree about the Avari, probably the most sensible of the lot but history is written by the winners Noldorin scholars.

The Fins: we've all been there! If a first time reader survives the Valaquenta, thia is the next place to chuck the book through the window.

Looking forward to the Feanorians!

Thank you for the review! Glad you liked it. The Fins did give me a headache! And they all had more than one Fin name........just to make thinks really complicated! What with the gods having more than one name and the Elves having more than one name.....aargh. And then elves like Finrod start giving themselves even more names......help!!

Oh yay!  I'm so glad you are posting this here. This is so funny and so spot on.  I absolutely adored reading it yesterday on Faerie, and truly did laugh out loud, sometimes explosively at a number of points. I'm really looking forward to your take on the rest of it.

I agree totally with your assessment of the Valar here.  "Meddling in things when they really should leave well enough alone. Not meddling in things when it was obvious they really really should!"  Yep.