Comments

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.

This is a really interesting concept. If I were to take this as my personal canon, I would have a hard time believing that she really HAD to take it. "but there was no opportunity to put it back with Celebrimbor in the room"--what a poor excuse! It does make me laugh though! As much as I like Galadriel, I am always able to imagine her as capable of all sorts of shady things! (I don't know either if I should blame, Tolkien, Peter Jackson, or myself for that lack of trust).

 

Thank you for the comment!

She didn't HAVE to look through Celebrimbor's things either, but she did anyway. And with her history, both of her family and of herself, she's definitely capable of being shady. I guess that lack of trust should be directed at all three (though I can't say anything about the proportions...)!