Of Linguistic Preferences by Robinka
Fanwork Notes
Originally posted as part of the Silmarillion40 event.
Fanwork Information
Summary: Some of the Sindar may have practical reasons to like their king’s edict that banishes Quenya from Doriath. (Drabble) Major Characters: Sindar Major Relationships: Genre: Fixed-Length Ficlet Challenges: Rating: Creator Chooses Not to Rate Warnings: Creator Chooses Not to Warn This fanwork belongs to the series |
|
Chapters: 1 | Word Count: 99 |
Posted on 1 October 2017 | Updated on 1 October 2017 |
This fanwork is complete. |
Of Linguistic Preferences
Read Of Linguistic Preferences
“Class!” The teacher clapped her hands to quiet the group of younglings. “I have something of great importance to tell you! By the order of our king, we no longer learn the language of Quenya for it has been banned from our kingdom.”
The children let out a collective “oohhhh”, so she gestured for them to be calm. “Instead of that, we will have more lessons in music, art, and history”.
While the class “aawwed”, Miniel quickly kicked her sister in the ankle under the desk to get her attention. “Good!” she whispered. “Beleg says Quenya has a pesky cojungation!”
(1) Comment by Dawn Felagund for Of Linguistic Preferences
This is really cute, Binka ... and totally believable both in terms of kids wanting to avoid difficult, tedious work and having (sometimes adorable!) mispronunciations. And even as a teacher, I'm equally guilty of being glad that the emphasis in English language arts has shifted away from grammar. ;) Nicely done!
Re: (1) Comment by Dawn Felagund for Of Linguistic Preferences
YAY! Thank you so much for reading and leaving a review :D I'm really, really happy that you like this litte fic!
(2) Comment by oshun for Of Linguistic Preferences
Shame on those lazy little buggers! So funny! I used to have a mental list of the multisyllable words Alex pronounced in hilarious ways, but they don't happen anymore and it makes me sad.
I am always struck by how terrible it would be if I could never use English again in public. I came close to that in my life once, and I remember when a friend called us from the U.S. and my husband talked to him for about ten minutes and then hung up and said, "He said to say 'hi' to you!" I sobbed, because I had wanted to speak English so bad to someone besides my tiny immediate family. I have never been fond of the language-ban. You did make me laugh though.
Re: (2) Comment by oshun for Of Linguistic Preferences
It's great to hear that I made you laugh :) I'm really glad that my little idea works. Also, thank you so much for sharing your thoughts about a language ban. While I think Thingol had his reasons, forcing someone into not using their native language is very cruel. It's like forcing someone into forgetting who they are. Very sad. Thank you for reading and leaving a review!
(3) Comment by Himring for Of Linguistic Preferences
That's a fun, lighter moment! Kids will be kids.
And it's even canonical, in a way, because we're told the Sindar were slower to learn Quenya, aren't we? So it was because of the "cojungation"!
Re: (3) Comment by Himring for Of Linguistic Preferences
Ha! Yes :D And the problem solved ;) Thank you so much for reading and reviewing!
(4) Comment by Hrymfaxe for Of Linguistic Preferences
This is so cute and funny! :D And I love the idea of Beleg talking bad about Quenya in the earshot of kids! Maybe even make sure they heard - and they are repeating what he says without really understanding what cojungation is. :D
Re: (4) Comment by Hrymfaxe for Of Linguistic Preferences
And they just can't keep their mouth shut ;) Thank you so much. Glad you like it :D
(5) Comment by hennethgalad for Of Linguistic Preferences
hurrah ! Sindar is much prettier anyway ! i mean, those names...
Re: (5) Comment by hennethgalad for Of Linguistic Preferences
Exactly! ;) Thank you for the review!
(6) Comment by Lyra for Of Linguistic Preferences
Hah! I joked just a few days ago (while talking about the difficulties in spelling Quenya properly once the /th/ sound for the thúle Tengwa fell out of use, but the spelling remained as it was) that everyone was secretly relieved when Thingol issued his ban. Clearly, this includes Sindarin school kids who no longer have to bother with "cojungation"!
Re: (6) Comment by Lyra for Of Linguistic Preferences
Perhaps, Thingol figured an excuse because he didn't want to learn Quenya himself ;) Thank you so much for stopping by, reading and reviewing!
(7) Comment by Independence1776 for Of Linguistic Prefere...
This made me smile.
Re: (7) Comment by Independence1776 for Of Linguistic Prefere...
I'm glad it did :) Thank you!