Yes, definitely! Wee baby Caranthir was my favorite, although will all that biting and constant emotional meltdowns did getting a little trying after a while. 

Right? I guess having quite a temper and holding tight to grudges, both of these things are okay as long as you are "true, and wisehearted".  But definitely not okay you are way harsh, bro. 

I wish that would've stayed! It makes for an interesting dynamic, I think.

Yes! This was one of my first Silm stories. And it was fun to revisit similar themes this summer with my Caranthir/Finrod story. ^^