Comments

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.

Both of the poem and the illumination artwork are beautiful. I hope you do not mind but the artwork was displayed today at Roisin's viewing. A lot of people asked me where it came from and who made it. I thought you would want to know your artwork was very much admired by many today and it will continue to be a treasured heirloom in our home. It really is gorgeous Dawn and I know it meant a great deal to Roisin to recieve it.

Wow, thank you, Almare! I'll add your link to the original poem here so that others can enjoy your work on it. (Unless you'd like me to post the translation as a second chapter and give you co-author credit? Please let me know if you do--I'd love to share it here too, if you don't mind! :)

This poem inspires mixed feelings in me, since it was made as a gift for someone who turned out to be very deceptive (she continues to hold the original ... grr ...), but it's definitely an instance where bad circumstances produced something that, it appears, brought joy to others. Like so much in life!

Thanks, Oshun. Apparently, the poem and illumination are getting new mileage on Tumblr, which I like, since it lets me associate the project with something other than what it was intended for. Had I had more time, I could have done better with the calligraphy and especially the illumination, but I'm happy with it, for a quickie job.

Still wish I had my effing original back--that was on real vellum! :)

I'm with Oshun very much - it made me hesitant to comment initially, but your work isn't cheapened by the events that transpired around it, and Almarë's translation is very lovely - I am not sure how, but it maintains the same feeling as the original. Wonderful work by both of you.

Thank you, Elleth. I was tickled to see the project getting new attention on Tumblr; I like that it's being seen for something other than what it was created for, and I'm so grateful for that. Replying to comments on coauthored pieces is always awkward, as I wish we could both respond, but Almare, if you want me to add a response for you, just let me know. :)