Flight Through The Dark by Tyelca

| | |

Fanwork Notes

For April's challenge: A Woman's Sceptre.

“I sell the shadow to support the substance.” - Sojourner Truth

Fanwork Information

Summary:

In the form of a swan Elwing flies over the Sea, carrying a Silmaril and looking for her husband.

Major Characters: Elwing

Major Relationships:

Genre: Drama, General

Challenges: Woman's Sceptre

Rating: General

Warnings:

Chapters: 1 Word Count: 2, 391
Posted on 8 May 2017 Updated on 8 May 2017

This fanwork is complete.

Chapter 1

Read Chapter 1

The light in her hands was bright and pure and blinding, and she jumped. During the fall wings unfolded and white feathers covered her body, which was now lighter than the foam cresting the sea and whiter than the stars. She soared, higher and higher, and the land beneath her shrank until it was nigh invisible. She flew until night fell and since Tilion was tardy, there was utter darkness all around except for the light of the Jewel. The stars had not come out yet. There was no way to gauge direction and the winds tore hard at her fragile body, but she felt the warmth of the Silmaril pulse on her chest, like a heartbeat that was just out of sync with her own, and she knew she had to continue.

She did not look back as more and more miles appeared between her and her sons, both still so young and so innocent. She had condemned them to death, she knew, for the Sons of Fëanor knew no mercy. She cursed their name, but knew their fate would be worse than hers and took solace in that.

There was a part of her that remembered the slaughter in Doriath, however young she’d been when it happened. They weren’t really memories, more like flashes and impressions, or something like a dream. She had been too young to understand what was truly going on, but now that it happened again - now that they did it again - she understood all too clearly.

The warmth of the Silmaril she carried flared up into an uncomfortable heat before subsiding again, and Elwing almost believed it had heard her thoughts, but that was impossible and she quickly discarded the idea. It was but a stone, after all; nothing more than a piece of rock. Elwing couldn’t comprehend the lengths the Kinslayers went to in order to retrieve it; willful slaughter of many Eldar, not once but thrice, tearing apart families and leaving children alone to die in the woods. Her brothers come to mind, their hair dark and faces pale, the last memory she has of them. There have always been rumors they survived, fled into the forest, but never was any proof found. And there are also the other whispers, telling of how the Kinslayers went looking for them and burned their corpses in a bonfire that reached to the heavens.

For a moment Elwing forgets to breathe, forgets to flap her graceful wings, and for a few seconds she plummets, down into the deep. Then she regains herself and corrects her course. She is tempted, oh so tempted, to turn around and return to Sirion, where she had sent her boys into hiding. She had never actually checked whether they were concealed well, only assumed; for her mind had been on the Silmaril, on the promise she had made her father to never, ever, let it fall in the hands of the Kinslayers.

From her earliest youth she’d been told about the evil they wrought and the Doom that lay on them, but now she wondered; was that Doom solely connected to those who slew kin? Or were those who let kin be slewed equally guilty?

Was she just as obsessed with the rock that even now adorned her neck as those who were prepared to kill everyone who stood between them and their prize?

Her body grew heavier with her thoughts and her wings lost their powerful rhythm, and against the wind she moved only slowly. Suddenly she felt the fatigue from using muscles she hadn’t possessed before for many an hour and she scanned the darkness around her for a place to land, to rest, but she saw nothing.

She longed for the comforting embrace of her husband, that single piece of space where everything was okay and no evil could find her; but she feared his reaction upon learning she’d abandoned their sons to the mercy of those who had none. And so she cried and her tears were made of pearl and softly fell down into the deep, where they remained until the unmaking of the world.

But Elwing flew on through the night for she had no other choice, and when the Arien rose behind her and colored the waters beneath soft shades of pink and orange she spotted a sail in the distance. Her heart jumped with hope as she approached and could make out the silhouette of her beloved. He turned and just for a moment their eyes met, and during that moment everything in Arda was alright. Then it was over, but a gentle smile covered Eärendil’s face and Elwing knew that as long as he was at her side, there was nothing they could not overcome.

For a moment the Silmaril that hung around her neck, and all its complications and implications, were forgotten.


Chapter End Notes

The one thing that's always bothered me about Elwing is that she abandons her twin sons, who were only six years old at the time (Elrond and Elros were born in F.A. 532, while the Third Kinslaying took place in F.A. 538), for the sake of a Silmaril, that should not ahve the same connotations to her as it does to the Sons of Fëanor; yet she chooses to keep the Jewel even after Maedhros warned them. She of all people should know the horror of a Kinslaying, and thus do all that she can to prevent another one, especially when her children are in danger.


Comments

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.


Beautiful writing! But it's your end note that I want to address first, because it resonates with me so strongly. The fact that Elwing had already survived a Kinslaying, and yet provoked another one, keeps boggling me. (I can handle the "she abandoned her children" thing, even as a mother, but I can't get over the fact that she could have prevented the whole thing in the first place!) It's heartbreaking to consider that some sort of peaceful closure could have been reached at that point, and instead, there was more bloodshed. Of course, after Doriath, it is also understandable that Elwing might take a sort of "I'd rather die than give you what you killed for" stance, but it is not exactly sensible.
But this is not the place to rant about that (especially since we seem to be on the same page)! Instead, let me express my admiration that you nonetheless depicted Elwing in a very sympathetic manner here, neither as some kind of saint nor as a monster who spares no thoughts for her people and her children, but as a highly conflicted woman who has to deal with the consequences of her choices. Well done!

YES EXACTLY! One would think that she did not make this decision alone, but talked about it with others; this means that she either ignored other's advice and knew what she was doing when she refused to give up the Silmaril, or that those others all agreed with her choice and are just as much to blame as Elwing herself. I'm glad I'm not the only one who's not exactly thrilled with Elwing's choices! (But it does give for very nice AU-ideas...)

Thank you so much! As you've probably already noticed, my thoughts on Elwing are a little harsher than I depicted her in this fic, but this way she was much more interesting to write, and I do not believe in 'black-and-white' characters. Everyone is a shade of grey, though some might be more close to the black or to the white than others.