Master Swordsmith by oshun

Fanwork Information

Summary:

Fëanáro wants to make swords.

Major Characters: Fëanor, Finwë, Nerdanel

Major Relationships:

Artwork Type: No artwork type listed

Genre: General

Challenges:

Rating: General

Warnings:

This fanwork belongs to the series

Chapters: 1 Word Count: 442
Posted on 8 October 2013 Updated on 8 October 2013

This fanwork is complete.

Weapons

Read Weapons

Nerdanel loved for Finwë to visit their home on the outskirts of Tirion, even more if he slept over. Fëanáro’s father seemed to fill the hole inside of him that, no matter how much of her love and herself she poured into it, could never otherwise be filled.  Every indication of tension in Fëanáro’s face seemed to soften and relax in Finwë’s company.

She walked down the hallway with an armload of clean sheets to put in the linen cupboard, still warm and smelling of Laurelin in full bloom. There had been no rushing to the forge that morning to work for Fëanáro. She had left him and his father nearly an hour before on the terrace off their bedroom, with a large pot of tea and a platter of breakfast pastries filled with fruit and cheese. The crusty treats were considered holiday fare in their household, but any weekend Finwë chose to spend with them was treated as an occasion.

She heard Finwë’s voice, resonant with compassion, “Ah, but, Fëanáro,” he said, “the Noldor were ever makers, experimenters, and explorers. We never sought to be fighters; we were not even renowned as being among the best hunters. But when called upon to be defenders and warriors, we did excel. But the task had to be pushed upon us in the outer lands. We never took it up by choice.”

“You think I work on perfecting swords and lances because I want to fight? That is not ...“

“Illegal weapons,” Finwë interjected. “Forbidden weapons.”

“The swords arguably might be. Lances are perfectly legal.” Finwë chuckled softly at the response. Fëanáro continued with renewed passion. “Anyway, who are they to dictate what is proscribed to us and who are they to presume to sanction what we do?” Fëanáro’s voice rose in a crescendo of indignation and anger.

“Hush. We would be fools not to take instruction from them, benefit from their wisdom. It is small payment to indulge some of their preferences. We need no weapons here. That is the beauty of this land. Weapons have become an anachronism. More tea?” Finwë asked.

“Yes, please,” Fëanáro answered, his voice that of a polite and always respectful son. The thought made Nerdanel smile. He was hardly that. “I hope you are right,” he grumbled.

“Of course, onya, it is no one’s business what you do on your own property, in privacy of your own home.”

“There is only one left with strawberry filling.” Fëanáro said hopefully.

“You have it. I’m stuffed. I would not advise raising the subject with Mahtan, however.”

Fëanáro chuckled like one of the boys. “So my lovely wife tells me.”


Comments

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.


Ah, the question of weapons pre-Morgoth in Aman! One of my favorite heresies. :) You know my theory that the Elves had weapons in the Outer Lands, and the art was not lost on the Noldor of Valinor. Although this piece is short, you nonetheless touch on the conflicts and conflicting emotions this might have engendered. I've always seen swords and weapons as potent symbols to them ... but symbols with different meanings to different people. I like that you show this here.

Thanks, Dawn! I suspect, like a lot of elements of my personal canon, I was first caused to think about the weapons question by running across your interpretation in your stories. I have no idea where this ficlet came from, at this time. I think I was wondering how complicit (it would be more passive than active I think) is Finwe in a whole series of things that Feanor becomes obsessed with. I don't think Feanor keeps anything from Finwe.

Recently been thinking that Feanor is at times Finwe's alter ego and at other times pushes Finwe out of a comfort zone, almost like a nagging conscience which he has almost quieted but never entirely. He is definitely an unsettling element for Finwe and also greatly indulged. In the end, Feanor means more to him than his duty, his wife, or his other children. One could do a lot with that.

Weapons in paradise is a big dilemna and interesting to me on so many levels.

Thanks for reading and commenting.