Tolkien Meta Week Starts December 8!
Join us December 8-14, here and on Tumblr, as we share our thoughts, musings, rants, and headcanons about all aspects of Tolkien's world.
In the silent aftermath of their flight, there is weeping. Maglor enters his brother's tent, sets his harp down softly and sits in spite of the pain in his war-shattered leg. "I shall make you a song for him. I shall make a song for all that are fallen, if it takes until my own life's end. May it contain all the grief you feel."
"No song nor tale can contain it all," Maedhros replies at length, quieting. "And not all tears are an evil, Maglor. At least he was not taken. He refused. He died. And that is mercy."
You know the quotes I lifted directly from Tolkien - the grief of the Nirnaeth not being contained in any song or tale, and Gandalf's "Not all tears are an evil", which strikes me as a sentiment that the Noldor would be well aware of.