Comments on Jubilee

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.


Ahhh that darned Elwë, hiding in the forest with his sorceress while his friends are anxious for him. I love this glimpse into beginning-times, and Miriel giving comfort to Finwë — I like seeing her strength before she pours it all into her son. A lovely one!

I just love this moment. It shows all of his hopes and dreams that are blasted away by dragon-fire, and also shows the hope he still keeps; and the final ironic sting, for us readers — knowing that this plant is going to be drowned by the valor ere long. Lovely piece!

Thank you! I feel a lot is made of Maglor's loss of the Gap in the Bragollach (including by me) but hear little said about Caranthir's loss of Thargelion in the same war, so I was inspired to give him a bit of attention for the prompt. I also had that headcanon about him being once interesting in plants nestled somewhere in the back of my mind. 

Kids will be kids, no matter how remarkable their ancestry and unusual their upbringing!!