Comments on Twinkle, Twinkle, Silmaril

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.


I'm currently looking into purchasing a new one, my usual for voice calls is integrated into my headphones, and those are still good, so I'm investigating the options for an external one that I can connect to my laptop ideally via usb/usb-c.
Once I find something, I'll put this on the list to record!

I love this! The art is gorgeous and the poem is lovely--and delightfully in line with Tolkien's conceit that some of our modern songs and sayings originated in Middle-earth and are just now changed around a little bit. <33

How lovely! Both the art and the poem are beautiful, andi I love the idea that the familiar rhyme originated with Earendil and the silmaril bringing hope and comfort to folk on Earth. I'm due to become a grandmother soon, and I'll be sure to sing this to the little one. :) 

I'm so glad you like my version, thank you! 

It's such a lovely calming, reassuring song and tune, I'm sure both you and your little grandchild will enjoy singing it. (If you sing the Eärendil version they'll be getting a very early start on The Silmarillion, and then I suddenly had this image of them arguing with their friends about which the real one iis. 😆)

Ah, I really love this remake of the twinkle twinkle song! I think the song suits so well in the Silmarillion universe, and your version feels like an older, now almost forgotten version of it. Like alternative history. Nice adaptation.