I love the tone of their conversation - both the serious and the banter. Came for the premise, stayed for the dialogue! (I haven't even read the next chapters yet, but I just had to get this out of my system...)

Okay, I loved this from start to finish. Possibly my favourite part was Elros' explanation for why he chose as he chose, but there are so many awesome thoughts in this that it's hard to pick one. I really enjoyed how you brought Maglor back to his people as one of the Released - that's such a good way of viewing the Oath. Thank you so much for this story!