Golden Lads and Girls All Must by sallysavestheday

| | |

Fanwork Notes

Written for the SWG Meet and Greet challenge, with the matryoshka prompts of 1) someone is hurt; 2) something never seen before; 3) looking into a mirror; 4) lost in memory; 5) you’re better than this; and 6) a shooting star.

Title is Shakespeare, from Cymbeline: Golden lads and girls all must, /As chimney-sweepers, come to dust.

Fanwork Information

Summary:

Argon sees the world with an artist's eyes. All the way to the end.

Major Characters: Argon, Fingon

Major Relationships: Argon & Fingon

Genre:

Challenges: Meet & Greet

Rating: General

Warnings: Character Death

Chapters: 1 Word Count: 969
Posted on 2 March 2024 Updated on 6 March 2024

This fanwork is complete.

Golden Lads and Girls All Must

Read Golden Lads and Girls All Must

Argon is surprised, more than anything.

Riding in the rear of Fingolfin’s host, he had not been part of the panicked, slippery misery of Alqualondë. Until this moment, he has never known the disrupting jolt of his blade striking home; the sick, slick slide of its withdrawal. That his arm moves as it has been trained to do is fortunate, for his mind is elsewhere, puzzling. 

He has never truly imagined what it would be like to be face to face with an enemy that hopes to kill him. The Orcs that descend on them are more monstrous than in any childhood tale, and yet they are somehow pitiful, with their ragged ears and their empty, almost-Elven eyes. No, this is not at all what he expected.

It is hard to hold onto his battle-fever when he keeps noticing things – his painter’s senses are flung open and wide. Here the starlight on someone’s armor catches his eye; there the arc of an arrow’s descent into the surging horde. He notes a tattered surcoat, flickering at the edge of his vision; the necklace on some charging Orc, metal and bead and bone almost elegant against its blackened hide.

On the Ice, he had planned his first works in this new land to be explosions of color: blossoms and auroras and great sheets of fire. But perhaps capturing the silvery fog of this battle is more urgent. He is not certain, now, that he will be able to paint flowers. He must first clear his mind of blades.

Argon stores up images and sensations for later, plotting. He will paint a mural, perhaps, on the wall of his father’s palace-to-be: silhouettes of their snow-worn, hungry people, stunned yet valiant in the waning night. Or a gray and black and starlit muddle that speaks to the bitter grace of the fight. Some miniatures, to remember those he knows are dying, even now. And a small series of Orc faces, overlaid with a shadowy rendering of the cramped and weary souls he senses inside.

Lost in his observations, he has waded far ahead of his assigned company when the blow comes. It, too, startles him – after all the buffeting, true pain is a surprise. He ends the Orc that has struck him with an instinctive backhand swipe, but then it is too much, and he is crumpling, sinking, falling. Feet are on his neck, scrambling over his back, pressing his hands down into the reeking mud. It is dark, under the scrum, and for the first time, he is afraid.

Fingon finds him there, in the new moonlight: the silver of Argon’s pauldrons gleams out of the pile of his darker, fallen foes. He hauls his brother from the heap and turns him to face the sky, calling for a healer. Argon’s eyes are wide and wondering, tracking the strange, pale light, trying to focus. It is so bright!

Exposed by the moon, Fingon sees his own face reflected in Argon’s cuirass: he is mottled and frantic, eyes wild, teeth bared in a furious snarl. Argon, in contrast, almost smiles. His face wears the look of smooth abstraction he escapes to when caught by a vision, conjuring colors, imagining brush strokes, gauging the perfect light.  

Always his brother has danced thus at the edges of the world, Fingon thinks: lost in his daydreams, his hands moving in creation almost of their own volition. The palace caretakers in Tirion learned quickly to leave the lower walls free of decoration, lest his childish fingers muddle older works or damage treasures. Young Argon left the fruits of his imagination in mud or chalk or paint wherever they struck him, without regard.

Finwë, charmed by the unexpected beauties that spilled from those tiny hands, had bordered and labeled them: Yavanna's Gifts, Carried Inside. Inspiration After Breakfast. View From an Interrupted Nap. Small Argon had been his favorite companion for gallery walks, king and child hand in hand, wandering, wondering. Fingon remembers them laughing together, bent over easels, rolling brushes on their tongues, coming to family lunches with their mouths still striped in orange or purple or green.

But Argon’s lips are red now, redder than they should be with the taste of his life leaking up and out of his mouth. The moon silvers the slash in his stomach, but the edges are raw. Fingon gathers him close, cries out again for a healer. The cold slows everything, but the blood in the snow beneath them keeps spreading.

“No, no, no, Arko. Arko, stay with me.” Fingon wipes the stains from the corners of Argon’s mouth; he rocks his baby brother as he had when he was young, panting with the beginnings of despair.

Loss he has already learned, and anguish, and regret. But it was Argon, alone of all of them, who came to him after the slaughter on the docks, cleaning Fingon’s face and arms and gazing at him with that deep look, that search for perspective. When Fingon made to rise, to flee, Argon held him still with strong, sure hands. “You won’t do it again, Finno. I know it.” Argon’s fingers had been warm in his own, curled as though around a brush handle, remaking him in some new image. “I know you. You are better than this.”

Fingon shouts again: for help, for forgiveness.

He grips the gaping wound, trying to force its edges together. “Arko. Look at me.”

But Argon’s eyes are still on the sky, on the new moon, and the darkness that lingers at its margins. They widen, tracing the path of a shooting star, as all his sweetness spills out into an ending, cupped in Fingon’s trembling hands.


Comments

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.


Oh, this is so good. First of all, I love the idea of Argon as a painter -- I feel like it's an art which, strangely, doesn't get much said about it compared to carving, architecture, jewelcraft, weaving, etc. In a way, it feels appropriate, like how we know the Romans loved their paintings, but vanishingly few survive. 

And, of course, it's crushingly sad! Wonderful stuff. 

Thanks very much! I fell in love with Argon as a painter last summer, when writing The Music of Sight for Scribbles and Drabbles. Now he just won't leave me alone. He's so ephemeral, in canon, it felt right to give him a more ephemeral craft. Very glad to hear that it worked for you, too. And mwahaha yes, I'm crushing you, I'm crushing you...oh, Arko :(

Ooh, I loved this fic! Argon as a daydreamer and an artist is a lovely portrayal. My favourite part was probably when Fingon sees his face reflected in moonlight- a powerful scene that has a lot of emotion and pictures the arrival of the moon and the new era so cleverly. There is something special in the atmosphere of this fic, well done.

What a loss!

You convey all that painterly wonder and also the grief and horror of it.

And it adds a specially painful twist that Argon was the one to help Fingon after Alqualonde, but Fingon cannot help him now.

Alas for Fingon indeed, yet I think maybe not so much for the sensitive soul that is his brother — he experiences the world so much more intensely, in such fine detail, I think life in Beleriand would have crunched him up and spat him out bitter, or mad, or both. But then again, there are all those years of the watchful peace which is but a few lines in the book, so maybe alas for dear Argon to miss out on the magic that was Beleriand. Either way, your Argon is now cemented firmly in my head canon and I love him fiercely and want to get to know him more.