Guileless Son by Kaylee Arafinwiel

| | |

Fanwork Notes

In mine and AfricanDaisy’s ‘verse, Carphadril is a queen of the Evair (Avari) who settled in far northern Greenwood. Two of her daughters married ellyn who became high nobles of Doriath, forsaking her to continue the Great Journey westward, and she desires the fall of all Doriathrin nobility due to their treachery.

In our main ficverse, though, she doesn't start quite this early to take out her revenge on the Iathrim. But the plotbunny I was given bit, and so...

It is prophesied that only treachery from within will cause Doriath to fall. (“Sketch of the Mythology”)

Also, it is National Poetry Month and I am including the B2MEM 2023 prompt "Haiku".

Fanwork Information

Summary:

Carphadril, Queen of the Evair, moves against the King and Queen of Doriath, a threat to her rule. She raises a son who - she hopes - will wed Luthien and claim the throne of the other great forest realm for her.

 

Major Characters: Daeron

Major Relationships:

Genre: Alternate Universe

Challenges: Rejects

Rating: Teens

Warnings: Check Notes for Warnings

Chapters: 1 Word Count: 493
Posted on 16 April 2023 Updated on 16 April 2023

This fanwork is complete.

Guileless Son

“Guileless son, I’ll shape your belief, and you’ll always know that your father’s a thief/You won’t understand the cause of your grief but you’ll always follow the voices beneath that sing/Loyalty, loyalty, loyalty, loyalty only to me…” - Heather Dale, “Mordred’s Lullaby”

Read Guileless Son

Carphadril smiled thinly, pacing around the pallet where Dairon lay, shivering under his worn blanket. The Queen of Gorthebar, in the north of the wood which would someday be called Greenwood the Great, had no use for boy-children - usually.

 

“Sleep now and dream,” she murmured, almost gently, eyes glinting. “Tomorrow, my son, your training shall begin.”

 

“Goodnight, my lady,” Dairon whispered.

 

“‘Mother’ will do,” she said, a hand ghosting over his pale brow, slick with sweat. “But remember your place, my little prince.”

 

“Yes…mother.” Dairon curled up on the pallet, going still as Carphadril tucked the blanket around his shoulders. Her kiss on his brow froze him, white with fear.

 

Still, he tried to look as though he was asleep. Why would the Queen of Gorthebar be showing him this special favor?

Just so she could take it away, surely. He cringed, feeling as though a bolt of lightning would strike him for daring to think such traitorous thoughts, but nothing happened.

 

At last, he fell asleep.

 

The next day, Dairon was called before Carphadril’s daughters, her staunchest supporters, who began his training in the art of slow poison. “Tell me, my son. How do you kill a Maia?” Carphadril asked Dairon, looking down at the slender youth.

 

Dairon’s lower lip worked between his teeth, and he gnawed anxiously, yelping as one of the princesses dealt him a sharp cuff.

“You…can’t? They’re immortal?” he hazarded.

 

“Unless you find a way to make them mortal,” Carphadril mused. “Shall we see about that?”

 

A frisson of fear plucked Dairon like a harp string. “It will be as you say, my l--mother.”

 

“Good boy.”

 

They worked on the blood poison for a long time. In Dairon’s spare time, when he had any, he was permitted to write his songs and poetry, and play his flute. It surprised him that the Queen would allow him any such indulgence, but when he was told of the dark power Songs could wield, he understood.

 

He showed Carphadril one of his simple compositions.

 

The blood, it flows red

From many deep gashes where

Our warriors have struck

 

She praised his effort, encouraging him to study the topic of blood further.

 

At last, when Dairon had grown old enough, Carphadril deemed him ready. “Remember what I have taught you,” she cautioned him.

 

“I will present myself at the king’s court as a minstrel,” he recited. “I will win the princess’ heart with my music, and ensure she bears you a powerful heir. And I will kill the usurper queen and king, so that they may not try to overcome your power.”

 

“My power shall not be overcome,” Carphadril corrected sharply. “But they say the fall of Doriath will come from within. I shall punish the usurpers for stealing my daughters away, and take my rightful place.”

 

“Of course, mother,” Dairon bowed. “I live to serve. I am yours.”

 

“Yes, you are.”

 


Chapter End Notes

In this AU, Dairon (Daeron) is the son of Queen Carphadril's consort with a female thrall, which is common practice in Gorthebar. She generally accepts his daughters as servants and forces sons to be disposed of for her blood magics, lest they become a threat. But a vision of how her traitorous eldest trueborn daughters - one the wife of Elu Thingol's brother and Steward- might be brought low causes her to keep her youngest stepson alive, for now.

Similarities to certain Disney villains, as well as Morgan le Fay in Arthurian mythology, are not accidental.


Comments

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.


Thank you so much!! Yes, very poor Dairon. I don't know if I'll ever add more to this AU, but the song is one of my favorites (I love Heather Dale's music in general, and she's a fantastic person besides being an amazing singer!!) I do kind of want to know what'll happen when Dairon tries to carry out the plan, but I have no idea right now lol.

Oh this is truly chilling! Poor Daeron, what a horrid stepmother! And I feel for the people of Gorthebar, it almost sounds as if the place was better when it became known as Mirkwood! I think Daeron is fortunate to escape her and enjoy the comparative freedom of Doriath...

Thanks Anerea! Yes, Carphadril is a terrible stepmother (but being a dark sorceress, it kind of comes with the territory, I think). 

I don't know if Carphadril was worse than Sauron, because at least the majority of her power was localized to above the Enchanted River (she enchanted it, I haven't yet figured out how or why) but occasionally she'd send out a specific messenger or two to complete a specific mission elsewhere, if her power felt threatened by some outside source. She wouldn't go herself and do the thing.

It's more likely that Carphadril is an unwitting tool of Morgoth (or Sauron, I suppose) than being a threat to their power. I imagine she was corrupted by them or one of the other Maiar in Morgoth's following, whether directly or indirectly.