Beautiful!! It feels so real, so like Celebrimbor would say to Annatar after all the things that happened! The Doom of his family passed to Annatar is a thing I have never thought of! Brava!

This is all around lovely!

I particularly like the lines:

When you wrapped the scarlet scarf around our wrists
I gave myself to you and you bound yourself to my fate

The scarlet scarf binding them together is such a vivid image of the seriousness of their relationship.

And:

The hand that was holding the reins slipped
And for a moment, at least, I made you lose your balance

It was real on Sauron's side, even if only for a moment.

Oh, love it! 

I like how you responded to this prompt!

The imagery of the poem resonates even although I have not read all of your silver-gifting fics.

I really like the poetic style of this piece!

This fits the whole vibe of the prompt (and the challenge) so classically!

And that last line is *chef's kiss*