just_jenni's Favorites

Jump to Favorite Creators

Favorite Fanworks

This is a Writing fanwork Guess Who's Coming to Dinner by oshun

Beautiful.  I love how you illustrated the differences between the Noldor and other Elves such as the Teleri and the Vanyar.  In Amarie's eyes Finrod is the 'bad boy' Noldo that her parents have warned her about yet to her he is irrestistable.  I thought this story had lovely description and wonderful character building.  You are so good at this sort of thing.

Fanwork Information

It’s a Years of the Trees’ story of Finrod and Amarië as young lovers, long before the rebellion of the Noldor separates them.

Major Characters: Amarië, Finrod Felagund
Major Relationships: No major characters listed
Genres: Humor, Romance Challenges: 10th Birthday Celebration
Rating: Teens Warnings: Sexual Content (Mild)
Posted on 26 July 2015 Updated on 26 July 2015
This fanwork is complete.

Favorite Creators

Dawn Felagund

I loved this story for many reasons, not the least being the complicated relationship between father and son so exquisitely told, as well as the wonderful descriptions and the overall mood.  This is one of my favourite relationships from The Silm, therefore one of my favourite fanfic subjects to explore.  Poor little Maglor being banged on the head as a baby.  It's intriguing to think that this might have been the reason for his interest in music.  Grumpy yet kind Feanor comes across well for me too, just when I thought he was going to be an ass and let his preference for Maitimo be known to his second born.  Great stuff, Dawn.

Kaylee Arafinwiel

I really like your take on the line of succession here.  Tolkien had left so many gaps in the history and lineages of the elves that it's fun to play around and create our own.  

I like your young Turin a lot.  And his conflict with Saeros is fun to read.

oshun