The Embalmer's Apprentice by Lyra

| | |

Fanwork Notes

Contains references to corporal and capital punishment, a rather medieval law code and colonialist attitudes that may be upsetting to some readers.

Many thanks to Elleth and Dawn for their proof- and betareading patience on the first chapters! I also owe a huge debt of gratitude to Himring, Whitewave and Thai for their unflagging loyalty and encouragement.

The Stars of WesternesseThe Stars of Westernesse

Fanwork Information

Summary:

Faced with the choice between execution or working on the preservation of dead people, young Azruhâr finds himself drawn into an increasingly political struggle between faith and power, tradition and new ideas - and a journey beyond his wildest fears and dreams.

Major Characters: Original Character(s), Herucalmo, Tar-Ancalimon, Tar-Telemmaitë

Major Relationships:

Artwork Type: No artwork type listed

Genre: Drama

Challenges: Akallabêth in August, Arda Underground, Middle-earth Olympics

Rating: Adult

Warnings: Check Notes for Warnings, Expletive Language, In-Universe Classism, In-Universe Racism/Ethnocentrism, Mature Themes, Sexual Content (Mild), Torture, Violence (Moderate)

Chapters: 69 Word Count: 446, 654
Posted on 4 February 2010 Updated on 4 March 2024

This fanwork is a work in progress.

Table of Contents

Well, look who wrote a new chapter after almost three years! So, off to Andúnië!

Matters of great importance are being discussed, people are playing in the sand, and Andúnië continues to be highly idealised. Somewhere has to be.

Azruhâr has impressed the right people; time to pick a fight with the wrong people. Violence warning applies.

Azruhâr does some heavy thinking, and has to appear at the palace again. Amraphel covers the research.

Things progress uncomfortably, and Azruhâr's good deed has unexpected consequences.

Azruhâr enlarges his household, has some awkward conversations, meets the executioner and the in-laws.

Another happy Andúnië chapter.

There is a lot of crying in this chapter, some of it justified. -- Warning for the death of a supporting character.

Warning for some violence, and the death of a major supporting character.

Aaand we have a new King.

Story warnings apply to the second half of this chapter. Not a happy one, I'm afraid.

It's not getting better. >_>

Torture warning applies.

Trial time!

Warnings for the aftermath of the torment and vaguely suicidal thoughts.

 

Warning for discussions of suicide, and the off-screen suicide of a supporting character.

Warning for animal death. It's a hunting trip, after all.

Time to explore the darker sides of Umbar (and of Lord Herucalmo). Violence/torture warning applies, I guess.

The trip to the mines has unpleasant consequences. Help comes from an unexpected quarter.

Azruhâr finally meets the apprentices. Intercultural communications are harder than expected.

Warning for some violence and talk about human sacrifice. What are we getting ourselves into?

This chapter covers some prompts for the Middle-earth Olympics (athletics; boxing; wrestling - both literally and figuratively). That is accidental, but I'm going to take it.

Another difficult chapter.

The spring festival is there at last.

Warning for athletic injuries and unnamed background character death(s).

This is a grim one. Warning for (non-graphic) mentions of childbirth going pear-shaped. If that's a touchy subject for you, I recommend skipping this chapter.

Warning for dark-ish themes and background character death.

A (short) chapter of returns.

Azruhâr has to do some housekeeping.

Dârujan is in trouble.

Some letters home are in order.

Azruhâr's mind is quite occupied, thank you very much.

CW for non-graphic mentions of contagious sickness (bacterial gastroenteritis).

Lord Herucalmo comes to the morgue. Long and convoluted talking ensues. There even is an f-bomb. Oh dear.

Not a fun chapter despite the fun chapter number. My apologies.


Comments

The Silmarillion Writers' Guild is more than just an archive--we are a community! If you enjoy a fanwork or enjoy a creator's work, please consider letting them know in a comment.


I think he'd turn to Eru directly (it's what the Unfinished Tales suggest to me), but yes, he is certainly lucky - and grateful - to have met them. I'm very glad that you like Amraphel, who is pretty much the driving force in their relationship. Yes, they're supposed to complement each other; neither could achieve as much without the other.
Thank you for your lovely comments! I hope you continue to enjoy this story. I'm finally finding the inspiration to work on it again!

Yes! They had to, eventually!
I'm enjoying it way too much, too. I'm afraid there's a lot of Britanny in Andúnië... except for the ceiling! I certainly wish I could see that in real life as well! I can't even hope to manage a painting of it (though I might try at some point). But a girl can dream...
As always, thank you for commenting!

Nice to have more details about how Amraphel and Azruhar met! Amraphel may call herself foolish, but she is astoundingly brave.

I see that Azruhar has hopes of the amber--even though he sees himself it didn't do the caterpillar all that much good. (And I picked up on that bit about the sand-castles--and the contrast to embalming.)

Considering how idyllic most of this was--the end of the chapter shows the limits of this idyll up quite sharply.

I rewrote this chapter about three times (seriously, I never produced so many cut scenes in my life! I hope I can use them at some later point!), so I'm glad you liked the background detail about those two - I dithered a lot on whether to leave that in or cut it out. Yes, she is quite brave, though presumably, she only really showed it after the events related here, when she found out just how different her new lifestyle was to what she was used to and what she had expected.

Well, Azruhâr only has to keep the dead from rotting. In that respect, the caterpillar's a winner. (Oh good! I figured I couldn't have a trip to Andúnie without touching upon this issue...)

Can't have the characters get too comfortable, though! So yes, the idyll must come to an end, and Azruhâr has yet another obligation to worry about.

Thank you for your comment, as always!

Yes, it's a culture shock in every sense! A very educative one, though.
Yeah, I have to admit that I'm such an unashamed Aragorn (also Elendil and Isildur) fangirl, it's more or less bleeding over to the entire line.
They can't easily relocate, unfortunately! Azruhâr has his duties in Armenelos, after all, and he's still only alive under condition of working as an embalmer. But I do picture it as a kind of safe haven. Which is precisely why Ar-Pharazôn later forces Amandil and his family to relocate to Rómenna!
Anyway, I'm very glad you enjoyed the city and the lords and ladies. I feel a bit uncertain about depicting Andúnie in general and the noble family in particular too one-sidedly positive - grim-dark and deconstructive sees to be the fashion of the day - but I just can't help it. So it's nice when others turn out to like that too. :)

I enjoyed reading about Lord Earendur's reaction to the finding of a Silmaril and the story of the "Good Man" aka Azruhar!  In my opinion, Lord Earendur and his family are really fond of him and not merely for practical or "utilitarian"uses.  I also  read and re-read with pleasure the love story of our main character and his wife--thank you for treating us to such lovely details and at a quick interval too.

You think so? :) Once again, I'm thrilled you're liking the details. Since the writing bug has bitten me again, I've been rather eager to get stuff written (and published) in quick succession before it wears off. It's good to know that the result is nonetheless enjoyable! Thank you for your lovely reviews!

Azruhar definitely cannot fade into anonymity anymore, he is right smack in the middle of the action.   I think the Crown Prince realizes this--he is quite bitter this Crown Prince!  I am a bit scared of him for Azruhar's sake.   It is good that Azruhar also has friends in the nobility and hope he is able to find a good embalming solution for the king.

I have made him very bitter, for a variety of reasons (the ones discussed in Andúnië among them). It must be annoying (aside from everything else) to wait and wait, and know that previous kings would long since had handed matters on to their sons, while the future Tar-Telemmaitë has to wait until his father's death (this is only the second time in history that this happens, so it probably rankles still!), which in itself is probably not something that he is eager for. So that's a dilemma, and yes, it makes him very volatile.

Azruhar is definitely a somebody now--I can somehow understand why the Crown Prince views him as a threat--he wants to drive a wedge between Azruhar and Lord Earendur.  I hope it does not work!    The Crown Prince is getting more and more scary and such an apt observer.  Thank you for posting such long, satisfying chapters and the quick succession.   

He is certainly a wild card, since he hasn't been taught any of the rules of politics and thus can't well stick to them. And yes, the Crown Prince is very observant and trying to stay on top of the game, of course. Not an easy place for our poor protagonist!
Thank you for your lovely reviews! I don't know whether I'll be able to keep up the fast writing interval, but comments like yours certainly motivate me to try!

Oh dear! I had a very bad feeling when Azruhar pulled out that pendant while talking with Quentangole and wanted to shout: don't do it! Although it's probably true that the Crown Prince would have got at him another way.

And I was feeling a bit sorry for the Crown Prince, after the preceding revelations, but now the pity has entirely evaporated again!

It was spectacularly stupid, but on the plus side, it was a public occasion. Otherwise, who knows? (I had a couple more unpleasant events planned but they aren't realy feasible anymore after these developments - this story just won't behave! - so in fact, Azruhâr got lucky. ;))

Well, darn! Here I was trying to make my villain a bit more sympathetic, but the paint's already peeling off again... ;)

You're right, of course! He doesn't mind this development, but he didn't actually plan on it. I don't think he's that kind of speculative mastermind; he is really more interested in the person than in that person's usefulness. Not a perspective that makes sense to the Crown Prince, though, and not one that Azruhâr is familiar with, either...

It is indeed!

Well, both of them have the problem of having neglected to make a plan B. ;) I also wanted to contrast them a little; for all that Azruhâr thinks very little of himself, he has learned from his youth to adapt and compromise, which is serving him better than he realises. Balakhil's had certainty all his life, so he is feeling quite helpless now that it's been taken away. I don't think he realises how much pressure he's putting onto Azruhâr, though. Rather, he feels that that guy saved his life, so he's responsible for it. Nor does he understand Azruhâr's situation at all.
As always, thank you for commenting!

A blast from the past! I hope it still makes sense in the light of the more recent chapters. The story keeps on doing what it wants (I should know by now!), and I haven't yet dared to go back to check for continuity errors.

Glad to hear that this chapter makes you curious for these people's future roles. As you know by now, they become quite important pieces of Azruhâr's life, so they should be (at least vaguely) interesting from the start. :)

Balakhil of all people! This is getting more and more interesting with every chapter!  Azruhar's noble character seems to shine all the more in the situations you put him in.  His wife is such a good sport too.  Felt a bit sorry for Balakhil--I hope he will turn out to be a loyal ally(?) or friend to Azruhar.  I feel he will play a bigger part someday especially when the Crown Prince becomes the King--but this is me just being a fangirl.

Oh, good! I was beginning to worry that the most recent chapters were a bit boring, so I'm very happy they aren't as tedious to read as they were to write. Balakhil is certainly not happy, although it could definitely have gone worse for him. You might well be right about his role in the future, although as yet I am very much uncertain what that future is going to look like! It'll all work out in the end (I hope)!
As always, thank you for reading and sharing your thoughts and feelings!

The last part of the chapter made me worry for Azruhar and his young family, his enemies are clearly doing intense background investigation on him.  I found myself agreeing with Amraphel--I suspect this is all courtesy of the Crown Prince.  You know your Crown Prince had me all worried I even checked the list of Kings of Numenor to check if he will assume the throne or not.  Silly of me, I know...but still he is quite scary.

Balakhil definitely has sufficient reasons now to be loyal to his new master. There were so many priceless moments here that showcased Azruhar's character and I also enjoyed reading for once, how Amraphel depends on her husband too in her own way. 

Thank you for updating this story! 

Wow, thank you so much for your reviews! I squeed when I saw that there were three new comments. As always, I'm delighted to hear that you keep enjoying this story, which keeps getting away from me. (I hadn't planned on any princely intervention in the matter of Master Amrazôr, for instance, but as I continued to turn things over in my head, it made a lot of sense. So Amraphel and you are very likely right.)
Yes, Prince Alcarmaitë will in time become Tar-Telemmaitë. I'm afraid to find out what else he has in store myself. He is quite scary, and unfortunately very powerful as well. Fortunately, Azruhâr isn't without friends, nor is he quite as weak and foolish as he believes...
You're exceedingly welcome - thank you for your continuing support!

Some heavy stuff, in here.

I shouldn't have been shocked at the Elendili having been executed, but I was nevertheless.

Azruhar is doing amazingly and his relationship with Earendur is really developing, it seems to me, despite the fears. He's daring to actually say things occasionally rather than just blurting them out by accident.

But the more of this stuff he survives, the more anxious I get about his future. For a moment, I was sad that he didn't have the chance to become a horse-trader-- before remembering that if he had, there would be no story and I wouldn't have met him!

And I wish he could mend fences with Tarik, but just now it doesn't seem realistic, I guess.

Yeah, it wasn't easy to write.

I hope that wasn't too surprising/unbelievable? I needed to illustrate that Târik's fears aren't all that unfounded, since the king is being rather mercurial at this point. So I hope it was shocking because of its harshness, rather than because it came entirely out of the blue. >_>

Azruhâr is growing (more than just sideways ;)). I can't really say all that much since a) I no longer dare to believe that I actually know where the story is going and b) I don't want to spoil you for future chapters (as currently envisioned), but FWIW, we know that Azruhâr is going to recount the whole tale much later, so he's got to survive long enough to develop senile dementia. Isn't that reassuring! (Well, under the current circumstances, it might be? He's only around 60 now, which is really no age for a Númenorean.)

Indeed, I would never have written the story of Azruhâr the Horse-dealer, although that might also have been an interesting one! As always, thank you so much for your thoughts and your support.

I especially relished the parts about the Eldarin guests! It made me wonder if there will be Eldarin characters in future chapters.

I really hope Azruhar soon realizes that his hosts genuinely like him and to relax a little  :-)  He is so lucky to have such well-connected friends.   Good thing the Crown Prince is not there too. 

I can't be certain, but there might be others. They will probably play only a minor role, just like the embassadors here. Originally, I had planned for Azruhâr to be sent off to Middle-earth for a while and meet Gil-galad and Elrond, but it no longer looks feasible at this point. So the Elves are not going to feature in any major way. Sorry!
He will, by and by. He does want to trust them, he just needs to let down his guard bit by bit. It would be harder if the Crown Prince were around! He is indeed very lucky.

I'm very glad Tarik and Azruhar were reconciliated!

It occurs me that, depending on the attitude of the King, it might actually be a little dangerous for the Lord of Arminaleth to be too successful, too. But that does not seem to be Atanacalmo's problem so much. I'm a bit surprised he wasn't embarrassed to say such revealing things in front of his daughter, but apparently she's in his confidence and he doesn't embarrass easily, even when he's sounding rather petty.

Azruhar seems to be getting braver almost by the minute. I'm wondering what "swimming" might consist in, for him, because the ice is certainly creaking.

Me too! And I'm glad you're glad. I know I'm violating the writerly "more conflict" rule, but neither I nor my characters can fight on all fronts at once...

Aaah, once more you're making such good observations and I can't properly respond to them for fear of spoiling things! Suffice it to say that yes, Lady Arancalime is very much in her father's confidence - actually, slowly preparing to take over the "family business". Atanacalmo is younger than Ancalimon, but not by that much - two or three decades? So he isn't expecting to make any great breakthroughs himself, he just stays in the game to pave the way for future generations. Which is, of course, where his daughter comes in...
You're right that he doesn't embarrass easily. He has adopted cynicism as a shield against disappointment, so to say, so most things slide right off him. Even Azruhârs criticism, or so one must assume.

Yes, Azruhâr's education is progressing - even though he's still taking things too literally! The "swimming", for him, probably consists in moving more confidently among the upper crust... and understanding people's motivation a bit better, perhaps! ;)

Thank you so much for your comment!

And I thought Azruhar found an ally---too bad it was not so.   But I'm glad that he and Lord Earendur were able to resolve it and that he is at peace with his colleagues and neighbors.  Azruhar surely does not need more enemies.  Very touching scene with Palatar.  Hope the embalming method works out because I'm worried for our dear daytaler--especially with the Crown Prince poised to take over soon.  Who knows how Earendur can protect him once the Crown Prince becomes king! 

What a treat to read 2 chapters in short interval!   I enjoyed the exchange with Lord Atanacalmo--it seemed to me like he was subjecting Azruhar to a prolonged character assessment (torture)  ;-)   I think the chess game was more of a stress test of some sort. It is hard to ignore the fact that Atanacalmo actually listened to Azruhar's suggestion to give his neighbors employment for the winter.   Yes, Azruhar seems to be growing a spine and I'm loving it!

And it's also good that Azruhar's family is growing--I'm enjoying his continued friendship with Earendur. 

 

 

Eee! Thank you so much for calling it a treat - and for being such an observant reader! You're absolutely right, of course - it very much is an assessment/stress test. Atanacalmo has an agenda of his own, and he wants to know how (if) Azruhâr can be made to fit into it. Glad that you liked Azruhâr's growth... and that of his family, too! Again, thank you so much for your enthusiasm.

I guess I don't really think of Azruhar as having been cowardly, or sullen, you know, whatever people say, despite being glad that he is gaining confidence. Possibly, that's because I'm not that brave myself!

He's surprisingly unaggressive for the culture he lives in, really. But he is capable of hurting people by losing faith in the wrong place or at the wrong moment, isn't he? I'm glad Earendur forgave him.

And I hope that whatever Atanacalmo's game is, it will turn out well for Azruhar in the end.

He's expected to live up to impossibly high standards! And it's his lack of aggression that makes him look cowardly to people who associate strength with violence, or a very proactive stance at the very least. He does have his own kind of strength, and it starts showing once he no longer has to struggle to put food on the table. I'm glad that you see it shining through, whatever Azruhâr says! He is not always the most reliable judge of character, least of all of his own! ;) (See also: losing faith in the wrong place or at the wrong moment! Though, as Lord Eärendur observes, it's been building up for a long time, and probably came out at the right moment, before it did any more damage. In all honesty, I'd planned to keep the question - is it really friendship or is it just a business relationship? - open until aaaalmost the end of the story, but the story maneuvered me into a corner that I could only get out of by settling it right now...)

I hope so too! As always, thank you so much for your thoughts and encouragement.

I enjoyed the scenes and reading the lines of Lady Arancalimë---for me she is like a Middle Earth version of a lady executive. I find myself looking forward to reading more about her, actually.  It's very encouraging that she and her father appear to be aligned with Lord Earendur on this particular topic (about corporal punishments) and I think somehow there is concern for the daytalers well-being (to some extent).  I think she also subjected Azruhar to a renewed battery of stress tests / observation--would be interesting to see her conclusions about his character and how she will interact with him in future.

Quite a milestone for the daytalers welfare society as well.  I'm excited to hear more about the next few chapters to see how they will fare.  Hope they will be helpful to Azruhar in some form or another.  

 

Glad you like Lady Arancalimë! I hope she's going to make further appearances. As this isn't relevant to the future plot, I can safely say that she and Lord Atanacalmo aren't actually on the same page with Lord Eärendur on that topic - they think that it's a useful tool to keep people in their place, teach them a lesson, etc., while he feels that it's incompatible with people's dignity in general and should preferably not be done at all. Similarly, the nobles of Armenelos are not so much concerned with the daytalers as such; however, they do realise that they make up a large part of the citizenship, and that it's dangerous to let them grow too desperate. Fortunately, that results in some policies that do help the daytalers' well-being!

I am so excited that you'd like to see Arancalimë's conclusions! It's sooo tempting to explain her (and her father's) thought processes and motivations, because Azruhâr is completely unaware of them (and misinterprets them, too). Sadly, I'll have to keep him - and the gentle reader ;) - ignorant for the time being. If I ever finish this story, maybe I'll be able to write the author's commentary on that - or it won't be necessary because they explain themselves at some point. Who knows!

Thank you so much for your thoughtful comments! I love reading your observations. <3

I suppose this was sort of predictable, since Tarik had more or less predicted it, but I hadn't seen it coming, just then. That scene with the steward was really harrowing.

I'm feeling a strong desire for Numenorean legal reform beyond even Azruhar's wildest dreams here.

But of course the Crown Prince is clearly planning something rather different.

 

Azruhâr wasn't expecting it either, just then! It was harrowing to write, too.

They could definitely use a massive overhaul of their legal system. I've actually toyed with the idea of mapping out their laws, along with explanations of how and when these laws came into existence -- I'm assuming a lot of them are more like customs and legal habits that were codified at some point, rather than something that was fully mapped out from the start. It would make some thrilling reading, I'm sure. *facepalms* Trust a Tolkien fan to write fanfic that needs its own appendices... (Probably not going to do it.)

Hmm, whatever makes you think that? I'm sure he has only the best for his people in mind! >_>

Felt very much for Azruhar for all the stress he had to go through in this chapter.  The scene with the steward was also moving for me--the situation seemed so very desperate for Lord Earendur to suggest those steps.

Azruhar has some very determined enemies but so far he is able to trump them all.  Hope he can sustain this "winning" streak--but I think it will only deepen the animosity of the Crown Prince.  I find myself not trusting Lord Atanacalmo more and more with each chapter.  I think he and the Crown Prince plotted on this particular incident behind the scenes.  

I am also enjoying reading about the progress of the Day Taler's Society.    

Yes, Lord Eärendur is prepared for desperate measures, although he certainly prefers not needing them. Lord Atanacalmo is playing his own game, of course! And you're certainly right that Azruhâr's little victories are not going to endear him to the Crown Prince at all.

Glad you enjoy the Day-talers' Welfare Society stuff! It jumped on me out of the blue, so I'm a bit worried how it's going to work with the rest of the story, and it's good to hear that you're enjoying it so far. Thank you!

Enjoyed the scene with Lord Earendur and Azruhar--Azruhar certainly needs one on one coaching. I feel that this recent reward will deepen the hatred of the Crown Prince and I feel fearful of what he will do when the King dies. Lord Atanacalmo is acting fishy (I think) -- he might want to "use" Azruhar either for amusement or something more sinister. Hopefully not.

Enjoying all the references to chess--this events in this story does feel like a game of chess and Azruhar has come a long way since the initial move.

On a lighter note, I enjoyed reading your description of Azruhar's new house--it sounds like a Numenorean version of Architectural Digest.   Hope there will be happy and pivotal scenes in this house--but there is also the downside that he will have less neighbors to "protect" him in case it gets messy with the Crown Prince.

Curiously enough, the Crown Prince is actually okay with this reward - he expects that it will put Azruhâr at a serious disadvantage, since (as you observe) he is now out of his familiar and friendly neighbourhood, and a big house like that needs a lot of money just to maintain. (Not sure I should be telling you this, but I'm hoping this is not going to become a plot point in the future so it should be fair game...) Glad you're continuing to enjoy my clumsy chess references!

I very much indulged myself with that house! XD It's not the most recent version of Architectural Digest, but it's definitely a very nice place. Not sure about the pivotal scenes! It may be more of a backdrop than a major setting. But we'll see! I really shouldn't predict anything at this point! Good point about the neighbourhood, too. He's brought some of his friends along, but he's pretty much isolated on that street...